Last week, I gave my input on Sailor Moon Crystal and upon an inspection from an article on Bad Critical Techniques by a guy called “The Mysterious Mr. Enter”, I realized that I am expecting too much of the past for this anime series. Continue reading
It is very common for a manga series to be made into an anime. Sometimes, the anime adds things that are not found in the manga to either give a different take or just to make sure the manga is ahead of the show. There have been arguments over which is better for each series: the manga or the anime adaptation. So, of course, some anime had been re-done to match more closely to the anime. In the case of Sailor Moon Crystal, to me, the original 90s anime and the manga were better. The main reasons: character development and expression (or in the case of Sailor Moon Crystal, the lack of it).
First, let’s focus on the main story of Sailor Moon. A fourteen-year-old girl named Usagi Tsukino is given a pendant by a strange cat, who tells her she is the legendary hero named Sailor Moon, and that she must find her fellow Sailor Soldiers and the Legendary Silver Crystal in order to find the princess, restore the Moon Kingdom, and fight the evil that is responsible for the destruction of the kingdom over a millennium ago. Over the course of the first season, they have managed to succeed. However, the series has not ended, as now they have to rebuild the kingdom and maintain peace on Earth from more evil forces.
Now, let’s recall of what I had said earlier about what made SMC different from the 90s anime. In the original anime, the series was stretched to focus on more fight scenes with some character development, particularly the friction between Usagi (Sailor Moon) and Rei (Sailor Mars). Because let’s face it. Usagi is not actually the perfect hero. In fact, she’s an irresponsible, clumsy, lazy, ditzy crybaby. Throughout the first season, Rei often berated Usagi for her behavior, particularly when she doesn’t take her role as a Sailor Soldier seriously (there have been episodes where Rei scolded her for forgetting the Moon Wand or for not coming to meetings). Over time, particularly when the Moon Princess is revealed, she saw Usagi’s kind and motherly nature when needed the most, making Rei (slowly) gain respect for Usagi. In Sailor Moon Crystal, we saw Usagi befriend Rei by telling her she is special and instantly Rei vows to protect her. See how the original anime was more interesting?
In addition, both the manga and the original anime had a balance of light-hearted comedy and drama, easily drawn in the character’s expressions. The manga had the characters drawn cute and cartoony when the story became light-hearted and slightly more realistic when the plot turned serious; the 90s anime kept that tradition from the manga; SMC had a more realistic, and somewhat restraining, expression and focused more on the drama. In short, both the manga and the 90s anime was more lively and expressive than SMC.
Another comparison between 90s Sailor Moon and Crystal with the scene involving Usagi and Mamoru
However, Sailor Moon Crystal is not terrible. I do appreciate them focusing on the main plot instead of dragging the series too much (this is why people tease Dragon Ball Z and why some people prefer to read the manga). Also, Sailor Moon Crystal is beautifully colored, but not exactly have great art with the very skinny character designs and the unnecessary CGI cel-shaded animation in the transformation sequence. Speaking of which, I appreciate SMC kept some the elements found in the transformation from the original anime, while at the same time remain faithful to the original manga story.
I still stand by my statement that Sailor Moon Crystal is nothing more than a pretty face. However, the anime has finished only one story arc so far and there are about a few more arcs left, assuming they still follow the manga. With that being said, I will keep watching the series with an open mind.
Nostalgia is a wonderful feeling, and sometimes we crave to bring back what had made our past enjoyable. Television networks recognized this and made networks just to bring back classic shows. I remember my Ma was filled with joy when the Nick at Nite channel launched, and she saw shows like “Room 227” and “Welcome Back, Kotter”, not to mention classic commercials to add the nostalgia. I was thrilled when Cartoon Network launched Boomerang, and I saw parts of the old Cartoon Network, from the shows they broadcasted to the classic bumpers and shorts they played through the break.
However, over time, networks like Boomerang aired shows that have not long gone off the air on Cartoon Network and Nickelodeon’s Nicktoons Network and Nick at Nite aired original shows and not-too-old shows. So, people would request a channel for nostalgia shows. This is a nice idea, but there are a few reasons why having something like this is not necessary. Continue reading